Desespero secularista na base do ódio anti-católico


Um bom contributo para a compreensão do quadro mental jugular: The Secular Inquisition – The campaign to arrest the pope is the product of an increasingly desperate secularism, which can only find meaning through ridiculing the religious

There is nothing remotely positive in the demand that British cops lock up the pope and then drag him to some international court on charges of ‘crimes against humanity’. Instead it springs from an increasingly desperate and discombobulated secularism, one which, unable to assert itself positively through Enlightening society and celebrating the achievements of mankind, asserts itself negatively, even repressively, through ridiculing the religious.


It’s worth asking why otherwise fairly intelligent thinkers get so dementedly exercised over the pope and the Catholic Church. What exactly is their beef? What are they objecting to? Very few (if any) of the pope-hunters were raised Catholic, so this isn’t about personal vengeance for some perceived slight by a priest or nun.


The reason this crusade is so hysterical is because it is not really about the pope at all – it is about the New Atheists themselves. The contemporary pope-hunting springs from a secularist movement which feels incapable of asserting a sense of purpose or meaning in any positive, human-centred way – as the great atheists of old such as Marx or Darwin might have done – and which instead can only assert itself negatively, in contrast to the ‘evil’ of religion, by posturing against the alleged wickedness of institutionalised faith. It is the inner emptiness, directionless and soullessness of contemporary secularism – in contrast to earlier, Enlightened and more positive secular movements – which has given birth to the bizarre clamour for the pope’s head.

Secularism is in crisis. In Enlightened times, progressive secular movements, those which eschewed the guidance of God in favour of relying on mankind to work out what his problems were and how to solve them, were all about having a positive view of humanity. Their vision was both terrifying and extremely liberating: that man alone could master the complexities of life on Earth and improve it for himself and future generations. Today, however, we live in misanthropic, deeply downbeat times, where mankind is looked upon as a greedy, destructive, unreliable force whose behaviour and thoughts must be governed from without.

Indeed, one of the newspaper writers who cheered on the vengeance of Hitchens and Dawkins against Benedict used the very same column to argue that ‘ecocide’ – otherwise known as mankind’s impact on the planet – should also be made a ‘crime against humanity’. It perfectly illustrated that it is not faith in humankind that drives today’s ‘muscular secularism’, but something like its opposite: a profound confusion about mankind’s role, a discomfort with the world we inhabit today, a powerful sense of isolation amongst contemporary New Secularists – isolation from other people, from any coherent ideas, from any stand-up system of meaning. Driven more by doubt and disarray than by a desire to Enlighten, the New Secularists come across as alarmingly intolerant of any system of meaning which, unlike theirs, appears to have some coherence and authority.

This is what drives their war against religion: an instinct for ridiculing those who still, unlike contemporary secularists themselves, have an overarching outlook on life and a strong belief system. That is really what they find so alien about the Catholic Church in particular – its beliefs, its faith, its hierarchy. An atheism utterly alienated from the mass of humanity and from any future-oriented vision can only lash out in an extreme and intolerant way against those who still seem to have strong beliefs: the religious, or the ‘deluded ones’, as the New Atheists see it.


About Mats

"Posterity will serve Him; future generations will be told about the Lord" (Psalm 22:30)
This entry was posted in Sociedade and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Desespero secularista na base do ódio anti-católico

  1. Nuno Dias says:

    Secularism is in crisis.
    Na Europa e nos EUA nunca esteve tão forte.


  2. Sérgio Sodré says:

    Ao contrário do que por vezes se pensa, ou parece pensar, o secularismo não tão anticritão quanto se diz. Na verdade o Secularismo deriva do Cristianismo, pois toda a realidade era sagrada antes do Cristianismo. É Santo Agostinho quem, ao teorizar sobre a distinção entre a Cidade do Homem e a Cidade de Deus, abriu o caminho ao futuro pensamento secular quando referido a Este Mundo, ao Mundo Homem, e neste aspecto o cristianismo é em certa medida responsável pelo pensamento secular (lembrar também o “a César o que é de César, a Deus o que é de Deus” – mais ou menos, estou a falar de cor).


  3. taty says:

    O secularismo surgiu em razão do protestantismo e de filosofias provenientes dele não do catolicismo…e a questão da cidade de Deus ( teocentrismo ) x cidade do homem…a cidade do homem é a cidade em que o homem toma o lugar de Deus, se coloca como Deus, o homem no centro ( antropocentrismo )


Todos os comentários contendo demagogia, insultos, blasfémias, alegações fora do contexto, "deus" em vez de Deus, "bíblia" em vez de "Bíblia", só links e pura idiotice, serão apagados. Se vais comentar, primeiro vê se o que vais dizer tem alguma coisa em comum com o que está a ser discutido. Se não tem (e se não justificares o comentário fora do contexto) então nem te dês ao trabalho.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s